Story of Inventions 2ed

Our Price:
$8.65
Retail: $12.50
You Save: $ 3.85
In Stock
Qty:
 
Qty:
navAdd to Wish List

Item #: 008682
ISBN: 9781932971200
Grade: 6

Additional Details

Publisher: Christian Liberty Press

Category Description for Story of Inventions

Customer Reviews

2.0 / 5.0
1 Review
5 Stars
4 Stars
3 Stars
2 Stars
1 Star
0
0
0
1
0
Great idea, disappointing execution
I chose this reading course for my 6th grade son who is very interested in inventions and how things work. I was excited to find a reading course about something that aligned with his interests.
However, I have been quite disappointed with it. In my opinion, this is not written for a sixth grade level, and not particularly well-written in general. I feel the level of inference and abstract thinking required to dig out the answers to the comprehension questions is above a sixth grade level. Even working backwards from the answer key, I had to really dig to come up with the answers they had, and I have a college degree with a minor in English! My son has been struggling with this curriculum and he is a bright student, one who is routinely testing at an 8th grade reading level.
Examples touching on the quality of the writing, often similar inventions or inventions that build on each other are discussed, but it can be difficult to distinguish one from the other and the questions expect the student to do so. For instance, chapter 12 covers the signal telegraph, the electric telegraph, the registering electromagnetic telegraph, Wheatstone's electric telegraph, and Morse's electric telegraph. The questions then ask what device did Gauss & Weber invent? The answer is the electric-needle telegraph, which is not even noted as a separate invention in the chapter. There is simply the passing reference in the section labeled Registering Electromagnetic Telegraph that "In 1833, Gauss & Weber, two noted German Scientists, put up an electric-needle telegraph line that was about a mile long."
Then once it gets around to talking about the Registering Electromagnetic Telegraph, it does not tell the student what the word "registering" means. Because I have an adult vocabulary and know what the word means, I was able to connect it to the rather convoluted description of this tweak to the invention being able to make dots on paper.
In short, while the subject matter is interesting and I applaud the author for choosing to create a resource that would be interesting to a child with a scientific bent, I feel the material is not well-written, nor is it written at a sixth-grade level.
November 15, 2017
Purchased
over 2 years ago
Start typing your question and we'll check if it was already asked and answered. Learn More
Browse 1 question Browse 1 question and 5 answers
Why did you choose this?
Rainbow Resource Center Store
trail guide to learning
Sara G on Aug 20, 2019
For homeschool
Patricia F on Aug 1, 2017
trail guide to learning
Sara G on Aug 20, 2019
For homeschooling (Ambleside Online, Charlotte Mason)
Jo W on Sep 26, 2017
For homeschool
Patricia F on Aug 1, 2017
Our co-op is using the Usborne book and I thought this would expand and add to that awesome book! We will see
nicole f on Sep 1, 2016
I am following a Charlotte Mason approach to homeschooling and this book was recommended. I can't find it at our local library, so I am buying it to use as our science read-aloud book.
User on Oct 4, 2015
For homeschooling (Ambleside Online, Charlotte Mason)
Jo W on Sep 26, 2017
Our co-op is using the Usborne book and I thought this would expand and add to that awesome book! We will see
nicole f on Sep 1, 2016
Customers who viewed this also viewed:
Other customers also bought:
Chosen for you: